B2B one-stop procurement, global machine tool accessories supplier

One-stop shopping for machine tool accessories

Evaluating CNC Tool Holder Performance: A Deep Dive Beyond Clamping Force and Accuracy

Created on 10.25

In CNC machining, toolholders, as the key component connecting the machine tool spindle and the cutting tool, have a direct impact on machining efficiency, product precision, and even production costs. Beyond the well-known factors of clamping force and precision, a comprehensive toolholder performance evaluation should also consider multiple dimensions, including assembly and disassembly speed, expandability, dynamic balance, maintainability, airflow avoidance, damping and vibration reduction properties, and price. This article aims to provide overseas machine tool accessory distributors with a detailed comparison of the performance parameters of various CNC toolholders, enabling them to better serve end customers and provide more precise toolholder solutions.

Seven precision metal tool holders lined up on a white paper sheet.

I. Assembly and Disassembly Speed and Expandability: A Dual Consideration of Efficiency and Cost

Assembly and disassembly speed directly impacts non-cutting time in the production process and is particularly important for machining scenarios with frequent tool changes. Hydraulic toolholders and some advanced quick-change toolholders offer superior assembly and disassembly speed, saving an average of approximately three minutes per tool change compared to traditional ER, SK collet, and high-power toolholders. This seemingly small time difference, when combined with 20 tool changes per day, can save a single machining cell an hour of valuable time.

Three precision metal tool holders on a white surface.

Expandability affects the versatility and inventory quantity of tool holders. ER and SK collet tool holders, with their diverse collet configurations, can hold tools of various diameters, achieving "one handle for multiple uses." Their expandability far exceeds that of heat-shrink and side-lock tool holders. [1] This wide range of applicability helps dealers reduce inventory and capital requirements.

2.Dynamic Balance: The Lifeblood of High-Speed Cutting

As machining technology advances toward higher speeds, dynamic balance has become a key indicator of toolholder performance. When spindle speeds exceed 11,000 rpm, vibration caused by toolholder imbalance increases dramatically. This not only significantly shortens the life of the spindle and tool, but also leaves noticeable chatter marks on the machined surface, affecting the dimensional stability of the product.

Graph overlay on CNC machine showing increasing RPM rates from 8000 to 18000.

Among various toolholder types, shrink-fit toolholders offer exemplary dynamic balance. Their one-piece construction, lacking redundant parts like locknuts and collets, and their smooth exterior significantly reduce windage and imbalance, making them suitable for extremely high-speed machining.

3. Maintainability and Price: A Comprehensive Assessment of Long-Term Benefits

Maintainability is crucial to a toolholder's ability to maintain precision and service life. Collet-type toolholders, such as ER and SK, are prone to retaining chips within the collet and nut, requiring careful cleaning with every tool change. Failure to do so can compromise clamping accuracy and toolholder life. Hydraulic and shrink-fit toolholders, on the other hand, have relatively enclosed structures, making them easier to clean and maintain.

Price and cost are factors of great concern to both distributors and end users.

ER collet toolholders: These are the most affordable and have the widest application range, but their performance in terms of clamping force, clamping accuracy, and assembly and disassembly speed is mediocre.
SK/SE toolholders: They offer improved clamping accuracy, but improvements in other performance parameters are limited.
Side-lock toolholders: They have a simple structure and quick assembly and disassembly, and are primarily used for heavy-duty cutting operations such as U-drilling. However, they suffer from poor dynamic balance and accuracy retention, making them unsuitable for machining speeds above 8,000 rpm.
Power toolholders: They offer significant clamping force advantages and good expandability, but they are slow to assemble and disassemble, and have poor dynamic balance and clamping accuracy, making them unsuitable for finishing.
Back-pull toolholders: They offer excellent clamping accuracy and dynamic balance, but weak clamping force and are extremely cumbersome to assemble and disassemble.
Hydraulic toolholders: They offer excellent clamping accuracy and force, the fastest assembly and disassembly speed, and are easy to maintain. However, their dynamic balance is average, making them unsuitable for high-speed machining above 15,000 rpm, and they are expensive. Shrink-fit toolholders: They offer excellent clamping accuracy and force, excellent dynamic balance, and are easy to maintain. However, assembly and disassembly speed depends on the performance of the shrink-fit machine, requiring specialized shrinking equipment, resulting in a higher initial investment cost.
Hydraulic screw-fit toolholders: They combine clamping force, precision, assembly and disassembly speed, and expandability. While their dynamic balance performance isn't as good as shrink-fit toolholders, they're sufficient for machining speeds under 20,000 rpm and are relatively easy to maintain. Their main drawback is their high price.

4. Airflow and Vibration Reduction: The Winning Formula for Special Working Conditions

Airflow is crucial in mold and die processing and the machining of complex structural parts, determining tool accessibility within deep cavities or confined areas. In this regard, shrink-fit toolholders, with their slender design, are the undisputed champion. Given the same airflow performance, shrink-fit toolholders offer far superior overall performance compared to other types of toolholders.

Precision drill aligns with metal guide.

Damping and vibration reduction properties directly impact the workpiece's surface finish and dimensional accuracy. The lower the vibration during machining, the smoother the cutting process and the longer the tool life.

Hydraulic toolholders: Because the hydraulic fluid inside them effectively absorbs and blocks the transmission of vibration, they exhibit excellent damping and vibration reduction performance.
Partially spun toolholders: These utilize internal damping rubber rings to reduce vibration, but due to their smaller contact area, their effectiveness is slightly inferior to that of hydraulic toolholders.
Cold-pressed toolholders: These utilize the differences in vibration frequency between different materials to partially dampen the transmission of vibration, but their effectiveness remains to be further verified.

Rotating drill bit with metal casing, showcasing motion dynamics.

5.Conclusion: There's no perfect toolholder, only the most suitable one.

In summary, no single toolholder on the market is universally applicable; it's impossible to fit all working conditions. Therefore, as a professional machine tool accessories distributor, a thorough understanding of the performance characteristics of various toolholders and providing the most appropriate toolholder selection based on specific customer processing requirements, machine tool conditions, and budgets are key to improving customer satisfaction and competitiveness. Furthermore, guiding users to develop good toolholder usage and maintenance habits can effectively extend toolholder life and maximize their value.

OLICNC® mainly manufactures Tool Holders for machine tools & Components for wood-working machines, as well as local Machine Accessories, belongs to the line of Machine & Tools. OLICNC® main products are necessary Tool Holders in lathing, milling, drilling, grinding, boring, planning, CNC Machines or Machine Centers, including variety of Spring Collets, Collets Chuck Sets, Mill Holders, Tapping Collets, Rough or Precision Boring Heads, Drill Chucks, Live Centers and so on. Meanwhile, OLICNC® can also supply Machine Accessories like Lathe Chucks, Steel Clamping Kits,Machine Vises, Bench Vises, Dividing Heads, Rotary Tables and Magnetic Chucks., etc. All these items from OLICNC® are in series of different common sizes; Besides above exiting ones, OLICNC® can also make and supply the goods as delivered samples or drawings.